The Gift Santa Didn't Bring
Rachel covets the American Girl dolls. Many of her friends have them and she thinks they are the Bees Knees. Her father and I just do not agree with her.
First of all, it is an 87 dollar doll. Call me cheap, but it is a cotton and vinyl doll. I just cannot see spending that much money on a single doll because I know what happens to dolls in our house: their hair gets teased within an inch of its life; they get "loved" by younger siblings; and they end up laying naked on the bedroom floor.
Secondly, when I researched the amazing American Girl doll, I found that the only depiction of a black doll was Addy, a slave who is forced to leave her baby sister behind when she and her mother run away to find her father and brother who have been sold away from the family. WHAT?!?!?!?!?!?
For those of you without elementary school aged daughters, each American Girl doll depicts a certain period in American history and is accompanied by a series of books that tell that Girl's story. On the front page of the web page it says, "American Girl celebrates a girls inner star - the little whisper inside that encourages her to stand tall, reach high and dream big. We take pride and care in helping girls become their very best today so they'll grow up to be the women who make a difference tomorrow." So, since they only have one black doll, they must believe that the historical experience that will best help my daughter "stand tall, reach high and dream big" is that of slavery. Not the Civil Rights movement? Not school desegregation? Not the Harlem Renaissance? And if it must be slavery, why not the Underground Railroad?
No,she should model her life after an American Girl with no rights, who is only counted as 3/5th of a person, whose family is ripped apart and whose mother abandons her youngest daughter to go looking for her son. And don't even get me started about how they gave the doll straight hair that flows all the way down to her waist further ingraining in little minds that flowing locks are the only type of beautiful hair.
Of course, American Girl appears to be an equal opportunity racial stereotyper. The Hispanic doll, Josefina, looks like she belongs in a Taco Rico commercial. Kaya, the Native American doll, has a nick name that translates to "untrustworthy and selfish." The only Asian doll, Ivy Ling, is relegated to best-friend-sidekick to the blond and gregarious Julie. Incidentally, although both dolls were introduced this year and share in the same book series, it was only the Julie doll that was unveiled on Oprah. What about poor Ivy Ling?
While the black Girl is escaping slavery, the Hispanic Girl is moving to a ranch to be raised by her aunt after her mother dies, and the Native American Girl is neglecting her brother, and the Asian Girl is playing second fiddle, the white Girls are having high adventures. Felicity is helping the American Revolution. Julie is saving endangered eagles and celebrating the Bi-Centennial. Kirsten is settling the American West. Kit is trying to become a kid reporter and helping to save money for her family during the Great Depression. Molly is keeping the home fires burning and helping with the war effort during World War II. Samantha is helping the poor at the turn of the last century. Am I the only one who has a problem with this type of characterization?
Now don't get me wrong, I am not the type of person who sees racism at every turn. In fact, I try to give folks the benefit of the doubt, but in this case there doesn't seem to be any other way to see this situation. Add on to this the fact that a few year ago American Girl made a sizable contribution to Girls, Inc., a group that promotes abortion rights. Also, there was the incident in which the folks at American Girl Place, the store and doll beauty salon (yes, you read that right, a beauty salon just for dolls) humiliated a young girl because she didn't have a "real" American Girl doll. Clearly, this is not a company with which I want to do business.
But here's the rub, Rachel loves the dolls. She doesn't know or care about the racial stereotyping, the abortion advocacy or the elitist attitude. All she knows is that all her friends have American Girl dolls, they are cute and she wants one. So what is a parent to do?
Some might say that we should sit Rachel down and explain the social implication of what American Girl stands for. Some would say that we should get a completely different doll for Rachel and try to convince her that it is just as good. Others may tell us to just get her a savings bond and be done with it. But, we didn't do any of those things. We bought a knock off and let Rachel believe that it was the real thing. Is that wrong? Perhaps. We never told her that it was an American Girl doll; we just haven't corrected her. And she loves this doll.
Rachel named her Lilly and has built a whole history for the doll. A unique story all Lilly's own, not one churned out by a company designed to sell additional doll outfits and accessories. Rachel tells Lilly her own life story in a proud voice. She tells Lilly how she was adopted, how Lilly is now her daughter and how she is going to be a good mom. When Lilly had a little mishap this week, Rachel told me, "I have to take care of her, she is my daughter." My heart almost broke.
If history is any indicator, Rachel's love of American Girl dolls will last until the next 1st grade fad starts. But maybe not. Maybe she and Lilly are about to have their own American girl adventure. I know that it will be a great story.







